The Employer Group is a small Wisconsin PEO, operating since 1995 and wholly owned by M3 Insurance since January 2023, that lets an employer buy payroll, HR or full co-employment separately and gives direct access to the people doing the work. It is a Wisconsin recommendation: neither CPEO certified nor ESAC accredited, very small by national standards, and concentrated in one state, so we move clients to a national PEO once they spread across several states.
We've placed clients with The Employer Group across multiple industries and headcounts. The assessment below reflects what actually happens in real engagements, not what the The Employer Group sales deck says happens, not what the affiliate review sites report based on commission spreads, and not what aggregated G2 stars suggest.
The Employer Group was founded in 1995 and is based in Verona, Wisconsin, outside Madison. Since January 1, 2023 it has been a wholly owned subsidiary of M3 Insurance, a regional insurance brokerage. That ownership is the most useful recent fact about the company: a PEO of about 26 staff, by its own team page, now has a brokerage parent with a benefits and risk bench behind it.
The company is small and local by design. It has served the Wisconsin market for three decades, has repeat Madison-area Best Places to Work recognition, and sells its services unbundled: a client can buy payroll alone, HR alone, or full co-employment. For a small employer that is not ready for a PEO relationship, that flexibility is unusual in this market, where most providers sell a bundle or nothing.
The Employer Group is on neither the IRS CPEO list nor the ESAC accredited directory. CPEO certification moves sole liability for federal employment taxes to the PEO and lets the wage base carry over on a mid-year start; ESAC provides bonded third-party financial assurance. Neither is in place here, and the company publishes no worksite employee count.
The Employer Group quotes per client and does not publish pricing. Because services can be bought separately, ask for the quote two ways: the service or services you want today, and the full co-employment bundle, so you can see what stepping up would cost later and whether the unbundled path is actually cheaper for your headcount.
The benefits line deserves specific attention. A PEO this small has little master medical buying power of its own, so the question is what the M3 Insurance parent brings to the table on group health and ancillary lines. Ask for the plan-by-plan rate table at your census and put it beside a national PEO's master plan; the local option sometimes holds up for a Wisconsin-only group, and the comparison is the only way to know.
Contracts are annual in the normal course. Confirm notice and exit terms in the client service agreement, and ask how an unbundled client's terms differ from a co-employment client's.
Most PEOs sell co-employment or nothing. The Employer Group lets a small business start with payroll or HR support and add co-employment later, without changing vendors. For an owner who is not ready to hand over the employment relationship, that is a practical on-ramp.
Since the January 2023 acquisition, The Employer Group has M3 Insurance's benefits and risk capability behind it, which gives it more bench on group health and insurance questions than a 26-person team would otherwise have. For an employer already working with a regional brokerage, that structure is familiar.
A small team means the person who answers is usually the person who processes your payroll or handles your HR question. There is no departmental hand-off to get lost in, which is the complaint we hear most about larger PEOs.
The Employer Group has operated in Wisconsin since 1995 and carries repeat Madison-area Best Places to Work recognition, which says something about staff continuity. A small PEO's value is its people, and people who stay are the point.
We frame these as considerations rather than negatives because most are real trade-offs rather than disqualifying flaws, but they are things we make sure clients understand before signing.
There is no federal sole-liability shift for employment taxes and no bonded financial assurance behind client funds. For a small owner-led business the practical exposure may be acceptable, but a buyer whose CFO or auditor asks for either credential should look at a certified peer. Ask for financial statements and references at your headcount.
About 26 staff and a single-state focus is a feature for a Madison small business and a limit for anyone else. An employer with employees in several states, or planning to be, should start with a national PEO rather than outgrow a local one.
The company publishes little about its platform. Ask to see the employee self-service and payroll tools in a demo before signing, and decide whether they meet what your workforce expects.
When a client is evaluating The Employer Group, these are the three alternatives we most often put on the shortlist. The rationale below explains when each one beats The Employer Group and when it doesn't. For the full comparison on cost, benefits and service, read The Employer Group alternatives compared.
The Midwest CPEO with about 25 local offices and a deep workers' compensation bench, for a Wisconsin employer that needs IRS certification or has blue-collar payroll.
Read full review →A founder-led PEO with both CPEO certification and ESAC accreditation and a named service team, for a buyer who wants the small-firm service feel with the credentials.
Read full review →A family-owned PEO of real scale with its own affiliated workers' compensation carrier, the comparison to make for a trades or franchise employer that has outgrown a single-state provider.
Read full review →A 15-minute call, then we shortlist the alternatives, gather quotes, and sit in the negotiation calls. Free to you, our fee is paid by the PEO you ultimately pick, at the same rate regardless of which one.
No. The Employer Group is not on the IRS CPEO list and is not in the ESAC accredited directory.
Small businesses of roughly 5 to 100 employees, with the best fit between 10 and 50.
It is based in Verona, Wisconsin, and its footprint is concentrated in Wisconsin and the Madison area. We recommend it inside Wisconsin and move clients to a national PEO once they spread across several states.
No. Pricing is quoted per client, and because services can be bought separately, ask for both the unbundled and the full co-employment quote.
The credential gap, no CPEO certification and no ESAC accreditation, combined with very small scale and a single-state footprint.
GMS is an IRS-certified PEO with about 25 offices across the Midwest and Southeast, more than 50,000 worksite employees and a deep workers' compensation practice; The Employer Group is a 26-person Wisconsin firm with an insurance brokerage parent and unbundled service options. GMS wins on credentials and scale; The Employer Group wins on direct local access and flexibility for a Madison small business.
M3 Insurance, a regional insurance brokerage, has wholly owned The Employer Group since January 1, 2023.
Independent 2026 ranking of 36 PEOs by company size, pricing and service. No PEO pays for placement. Find your fit, then get a free side-by…
What a Certified PEO means, when CPEO status matters, when it doesn't, and how to verify it, written by an independent PEO broker.
The real pros and cons of using a PEO, written by brokers who place clients with PEOs every week. Honest failure modes others won't admit.
Independent reviews of every major PEO: TriNet, Insperity, ADP TotalSource, Justworks, and more. Written by a broker, not an affiliate.
Independent broker's review of Group Management Services (GMS).
Independent broker's review of Nextep.